Josei Manga Reviews

In Clothes Called Fat

Noko is a binge-eater, she suffers from major depression due to crippling insecurity issues and the stress of being bullied at work. To cope with her depressive episodes she eats and eats and continues to eat until she can forget everything. As Noko’s binge eating spirals out of control so too does her weight, which makes her feel even more insecure about her body. Noko is trapped in a vicious cycle of shame over her body and gorging herself. She is emotionally dependent on her boyfriend, Saitou, who is manipulative and uses her.

In order to solve her problems with other people Noko decides to lose weight, but in her frenzy she develops an eating disorder. In Clothes Called Fat is by no means an easy read – it tackles an extremely difficult topic with brutal honesty. It shows that eating disorders aren’t simply dieting, but are actually a severe mental illness that can quickly turn deadly and destroy the lives of those suffering from them.

โ€œYou blame others for you gaining weight, but that’s your body we’re talking about here.โ€

I think I would have liked this manga more if certain characters and plot points weren’t so absurd. There is a clear antagonist that’s just out to make the main character’s life miserable and the plot with her is just so over the top it borders on not being believable. Side characters like Tabata and Fujimoto are almost comical and serve strange purposes in the story. I understand why some of these characters were introduced, as anyone losing weight will know there will always be mixed reactions from other people. There are those that will be discouraging of a person’s weight loss for various selfish reasons such as insecurity or because of a fetish, and in worse cases to keep someone down so that they can feel superior.

If the story had focused more on Noko’s private inner journey and less on the drama of these other characters this would have been a five star read for me. The aesthetician’s commentary about Noko’s destructive weight gain and weight loss is startlingly honest: that Noko is doomed because she is so wrapped up in how others perceive her and because of that she will continue to harm herself. This manga is definitely not a feel good weight loss and redemption story, it is dark, cynical, and quite frankly a wake up call for young people that weigh their happiness and self worth by how they look.

Title: In Clothes Called Fat
Author: Moyoco Anno
Publisher: Shodensha, Vertical
Publication Date: July 22, 2014
Serialized: 1996โ€“1997
Volumes: 1
Format: Paperback
Source: Read Online

Noko appears to be living a great life, she’s got a good job and a loving boyfriend, but beneath a thin veneer is a young woman who is struggling with her self-image and self-confidence as she fights to keep her weight down. To Noko, being 5 pounds overweight means being miles away from happiness in her lovelife and in her work-place.


  1. Evelina

    I gotta say, that name definitely hooked me in ๐Ÿ˜€ it is Japanese… and their stories are often very straightforward like that. So I kind of expected this. Nice review ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Yeah when I saw the title and cover it really caught my eye. I also agree that Japanese stories tend to be very direct when talking about difficult issues, but I actually really like it even if it can make J lit extremely difficult to digest sometimes. Thank you as always Evelina! <3

  2. I think you made great points, and is probably why I didn’t love this book. But I was honestly shocked that it was all about “your weight isn’t the issue, it’s your emotions and mental stability” coming from Japan. I personally liked Ink In Water, by Lacy Davis and Jim Kettner, which did a better job tackling that inner dialogue of self improvement. The only downside with their book is that it is less teen friendly. I mean I wouldn’t bat and eye if I see a 16 year old reading their book, but I know some conservative parents wouldn’t like it (nudity, drinking, queer themes, etc)
    Jennifer recently posted…Blog Recipe Round Up: Slow CookerMy Profile

    1. I’ll check the book out, thanks for the rec Jenn! And yeah I agree, I was looking at my shelves and realized I didn’t remember much about this manga and lost my old review for it, so I did a re-read. While I think I like it better than I did before and can better appreciate some of the core message, I agree that it’s pretty harsh.

  3. Interesting title and this manga touches on a series topic. I’ll probably check this out. Great review!

    1. Yeah the title really catches the attention, if you do check it out I hope you enjoy it. Thanks for stopping by Michelle. ๐Ÿ™‚

  4. Sounds like some hard-hitting subject material! A pity that there were aspects that diluted the message, I think sometimes creators struggle as much as readers when they’re dealing with tough topics.

    Great review btw! ๐Ÿ™‚
    Cee Arr recently posted…Nerd Church – Rebel Valentine 2: Return of the Candy HeartsMy Profile

    1. I think so too, this manga definitely had some silly side plots typical to anime and a heavy focus on a ridiculous antagonist that I found really distracting. It was still a great manga though that handled the subject matter really well.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge