Historical Romance Book Reviews

The Maid of Milan

themaidofmilan-eikliAdelaide is a young wife with a past full of scandal who has come to love a husband she was pushed into marrying to save her reputation. While at first she doesn’t care for Tristan, after getting to know the good person and even better husband that he is she falls in love with him. After years of living with guilt over the lies she’s forced to live with and the unsteady beginnings of her marriage, Adelaide’s quiet life is upset when the love of her past reappears. Instead of the expected rekindling of a lost love due to circumstance, the story took an unexpected turn, with Adelaide wanting nothing but to put the past behind her. The Maid of Milan is a story of regret and finding new love in unexpected places.

What I liked was how realistically love is portrayed. There are so many love stories where characters fall in love upon meeting with a fiery passion and continue to forge the relationship despite any of the difficulties that stand in their way. This is the kind of love I think everyone envisions, even though in reality the fire often burns out and couples end up struggling with each other’s imperfections. Adelaide and Tristan’s love for each other was born out of quiet patience and tenderness, getting to know the other person over time as passion grew between them. For Adelaide, true love started off as a compromise but became so much more. As her love grew, so did her guilt over both the past and for not sharing the same admiration at the start of the marriage. She holds her husband in the highest regard and worries about tarnishing his opinion of her.

Real love is complex. Very often, a working relationship requires compromise and learning to love, to respect, and to grow together. Sometimes in relationships you have to put aside your pride in order to make things work, sometimes you have to forgive no matter how much it hurts, and often times you just have to be brave and honest with yourself and your partner. This is the truth of love and marriage. I appreciated how the story attempted to illustrate the difference between two very different kinds of love, and how the slow and difficult kind can still last and become passionate.

“She’d hated herself for what she’d been given to believe were wicked traits. She’d been told so many times she’d been born to sin, it was inevitable she’d fulfill the prophecies.”

What I did find a little hard to believe at times were the timelines and just how convenient certain things were. I noted early on how the first wives of both Tristan and James conveniently died around the same time, and that the timing of James’ freedom from Hortense just happened to be within hours of Adelaide’s marriage. All of these little coincidences of course make every character innocent to circumstances that are out of their control at least in some way. It also seems that everyone has some dirty little secret. Everyone cheats, had cheated, or had a child out of wedlock but it’s okay because everything is justified and it’s not really cheating. That made me roll my eyes just a little.

Adelaide is an intriguing heroine, though at times I did not like how unstable her emotions were, with her thoughts often swinging wildly. Despite how intelligent, beautiful and loyal she is, she was still foolish for most of the book, trying fruitlessly to take control of her life and often just making things worse. For the most part I could sympathize with her and still did in the end, though there was one point where I just got downright mad. She had the opportunity to face her past and reveal the things that she needed to, but instead decided to cower when faced with a way out. Instead she let another person yet again take charge of everything and happily swept troubling matters under the rug. While I get that this is part of the point of her character, that for much of her life she has never been in control and has thus succumbed to a form of learned helplessness, this still bothered me. I suppose though that maybe it’s because this kind of characterization hits close to home. Despite my annoyance with her, Adelaide is a well developed character who, although deeply flawed, has some good points as well.

Many of the antagonists in the story truly are despicable, particularly Mrs. Henley, Adelaide’s mother who is easy to hate. Funny enough though, she is absolutely right in some regards as to the ugly personalities of some of the side characters. One in particular I am still pretty darn mad at for damning so many characters due to their selfishness, even with all of the coincidences and honest feelings on their side as if they are a victim themselves. This character also served as a true lesson as to how blind love can destroy everything, even the person you care about the most despite all the best of intentions.

Overall The Maid of Milan was a pleasurable read. There is a whole lot of drama to keep the story moving fast and tension high as the story progressed. I felt apprehension while reading most of the book and even though I was expecting the eventual climax, the story still managed quite a few surprises. It stands out from other historical romance novels for it’s unique cast of characters whose flaws make them pretty believable.

Title: The Maid of Milan
Author: Beverley Eikli
Publisher: Choc Lit
Publication Date: February 2, 2014
Pages: 356
Format: Ebook
Source: Blog Tour

How much would you pay for a clear conscience?
Adelaide Leeson wants to prove herself worthy of her husband, a man of noble aspirations who married her when she was at her lowest ebb.
Lord Tristan Leeson is a model of diplomacy and self-control, even curbing the fiery impulses of his youth to maintain the calm relations deemed essential by his mother-in-law to preserve his wife’s health.
A visit from his boyhood friend, feted poet Lord James Dewhurst, author of the sensational Maid of Milan, persuades Tristan that leaving the countryside behind for the London Season will be in everyone’s interests.
But as Tristan’s political career rises and Adelaide revels in society’s adulation, the secrets of the past are uncovered. And there’s a high price to pay for a life of deception.


  1. Hallo, Hallo Jamie!

    This was my second Ms Eikli novel – I started with The Reluctant Bride which I absolutely adored! One reason I became so smitten with ChocLit novels is how realistic the stories are – you can move through their sub-genres of Roms and find the same believablity! You’ll find this on my reviews for ChocLit – as I have become quite addicted to their writing styles – of honestly portraying characters in different stages of their lives, trying to make a go of a relationship, family ties, a career – or everything that comes before marriage – as generally speaking most are still in the dating and/or long-term relationship stage but there are supporting characters too! I love all the different scenarios, careers and different entrance points! I’ve never been bored! IF anything, I find each one – whether Historical or Contemporary to be breath of fresh air – have you picked up any others!? I have only found two which weren’t my cuppa; both Contemporaries. I lean more towards their Historicals, but I like the Contemporaries which have a bit of Suspense threaded into them! Some of which have kept me up! lol

    Definitely read her other ChocLit title – I think you will be happily surprised! I was a bit surprised when I picked up this one – as it felt like a departure in style and context from her debut. I found my way with it though – and we made similar points on which characters resonated with us and which ones irked our ires! Even when I love reading ChocLit, there are sometimes certain aspects of the story and/or how it was written (ie. language) which might wrinkle my brow & I mention this on my reviews. I like how you do the same! You talk about what unsettles you and what uplifts you – this review is not only balanced but I could feel how you *felt!* as you were reading it! #awesomesauce!

    Here are my thoughts: My Review of the Story .

    1. Jamie

      I’m glad you like the review Jorie, I definitely try to have balanced and fair reviews. 🙂
      I have not picked up other books from ChocLit yet (though I should!) but I have picked up some of Beverley’s other books written under her other name, Beverley Oakley. I’m not sure what the difference is between her two pen names but after reading Maid of Milan, I’ll read almost anything that she writes. I loved how the characters and relationships felt more real to me and were so much more convincing than most of the romances that I read, which are usually insta-love scenarios.

      I have a pile of romance novels to catch up on, maybe I’ll start that up again soon! Thanks for stopping by Jorie! ❤

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge