YA Contemporary Romance Book Reviews

When Dimple Met Rishi

Sigh. It’s hard for me to decide how to start this review because I found myself confused and disappointed when I finished. I think I suffered a little bit from overhype about this book since it was recommended so highly and talked about like mad over the summer. I wanted to love this book because everything just sounded so perfect: a strong willed STEM girl heroine, a clash between cultures, a sweet summer romance with lots of laughs, and one of the cutest book covers I’ve seen in a long time–I was all over it!

I absolutely adored the first half of this book. I could sympathize with both of the main characters, especially Dimple, whose mother reminded me of my own. I too was that nerdy awkward girl that felt uncomfortable wearing makeup and dresses and found happiness in front of a computer screen grinding out code to make websites and browser games. Like my mom, Dimple’s mother pushes her to be more feminine and doesn’t fully understand modern western culture. Dimple struggles with feeling like an outsider in both of her worlds, an experience shared by many American children with immigrant parents. It made me happy that this duality is explored in the novel as I think it’s important for children and teens that, like me, had difficulties with their cultural identity.

On the other hand there’s Rishi, who embraces his cultural heritage and doesn’t care whether or not he “fits in” with either group. He is still a modern young man adapted to western culture that also values tradition and believes with all of his heart in the fairy tale romance of his parents. He is exceptionally sweet and witty and is pretty much the ideal cute nerd boyfriend. The romance between Dimple and Rishi is swoon-worthy and made my heart melt.. Which was great for exactly half of the book.

“I feel like I need to speak out, because if no one speaks out, if no one says, this is me, this is what I believe in, and this is why I’m different, and this is why that’s okay, then what’s the point? What’s the point of living in this beautiful, great melting pot where everyone can dare be anything they want to be?”

With the Insomnia Con setting what I expected was a summer “coding camp” similar to ones like the Make School Summer Academy and others held on college campuses around the country every year. Many of these camps usually offer workshops to practice making programs, opportunities to make professional connections and to meet industry leaders, and very often have competitions where attendees can create and submit their own apps for a cool cash prize. I guess my expectations were misplaced because what I got, sadly, was high school drama with hook ups and a talent show that turned more into a dance competition? Dance? In a coding camp??

This was the start of when the book stopped working for me.

A large part of Dimple’s story revolves around her desire to develop her own app to catapult her into a successful tech career. The book talks at length about how much this matters to her, how she’s dying to make connections to help her on her way, and how she’s so different from other girls by being interested in coding. The book tells the reader all of these things but fails to actually show the reader these things. It’s easy to forget that the main characters are even at a coding camp because so little time is spent on it. The plot just gets plain weird and doesn’t seem to have any sort of focus, even the romance felt rushed.

Also I’m sorry, the dance competition was exceedingly boring to read. That and, well, the love story has already happened by then so the build up for that is finished as well. So what else was there? I thought heavily about skimming or just putting the book down at that point but I honestly wanted to know if Dimple would win the competition (the app one, not the dance one) and achieve her dream of becoming a high powered STEM girl. I was still optimistic that the book would get back to the code camp, but it never does. In fact, three weeks out of the six week camp is skipped completely as the story fast forwards to the result of the app completion. The more I read the more disappointed I was as the plot became more and more juvenile.

By the 3/4 mark it seemed like there was no story left to tell and was starting to seriously drag. So of course there had to be some drama to keep it going. I hated this part. Dimple’s actions in the later portion of the book left me feeling confused because they didn’t make any sense whatsoever. It was frustrating and I quite frankly got a little mad at how Dimple treated Rishi in an attempt to keep the story going. Such a shame considering how amazing the story set up was and how strong the early chapters were.

The characters drift from dinners, parties, and dance practices with next to no time actually coding and it made for a surprisingly boring and mediocre read for me personally. Even despite my criticisms, When Dimple Met Rishi is still a sweet summer romance that shined in the first half of the book. Just because it didn’t work out so well for me doesn’t mean that it won’t work out for others, in fact I seem to be in quite the minority with my opinions about this book. The book definitely had a lot of potential and I honestly wish that the tech girl part of the story could have been developed better and for the setting to be a little more convincing.



Title: When Dimple Met Rishi
Author: Sandhya Menon
Publisher: Simon Pulse
Publication Date: May 30, 2017
Pages: 384
Format: Hardcover
Source: Library
addtogoodreads

Synopsis
Dimple Shah has it all figured out. With graduation behind her, she’s more than ready for a break from her family, from Mamma’s inexplicable obsession with her finding the “Ideal Indian Husband.” Ugh. Dimple knows they must respect her principles on some level, though. If they truly believed she needed a husband right now, they wouldn’t have paid for her to attend a summer program for aspiring web developers…right?

Rishi Patel is a hopeless romantic. So when his parents tell him that his future wife will be attending the same summer program as him—wherein he’ll have to woo her—he’s totally on board. Because as silly as it sounds to most people in his life, Rishi wants to be arranged, believes in the power of tradition, stability, and being a part of something much bigger than himself.

The Shahs and Patels didn’t mean to start turning the wheels on this “suggested arrangement” so early in their children’s lives, but when they noticed them both gravitate toward the same summer program, they figured, Why not?

Dimple and Rishi may think they have each other figured out. But when opposites clash, love works hard to prove itself in the most unexpected ways.

6 Comments

  • Rekha

    Awww, it’s a shame you didn’t like this. I’ve read so many meh/negative reviews on this lately! I wasn’t very keen to read this before, but now it’s definitely not going on my TBR. Everyone has mentioned the dance competition, and it seems like the stereotype from Bollywood movies where people spontaneously burst into song and dance came into play. Hopefully you’ll enjoy your next read more 😀

    • Jamie

      I was thinking the same about the dance competition. On one end I thought, “Yay! Bollywood is awesome!” and is a great part of Indian culture that is well known in the West, but on the other end it also feels really stereotypical? There is much more to India than Bollywood. I guess I expected too much with the whole tech girl at code camp storyline, it was one of the parts of the synopsis that drew me in.

  • Jennifer

    Super bummer about the ending. I was hoping for a good review because well… I got sucked in by the cover too lol. I think the whole lack of coding would drive me nuts as well. Maybe the author didn’t know anything about coding? Or perhaps there was pressure from the editor to make it more summer camp esque?

    • Jamie

      Same, I was so excited to read it and enjoyed it for the first couple of chapters but ended up bored the more I read. I suspect it’s more of the former of what you mentioned because I just didn’t get that vibe while reading.

      Ah well, the author has two more books planned, one of them seems to be a spin off, so who knows? Maybe those will be better, I’d be willing to give them a shot.

  • Evelina

    Great review 🙂 dance in coding camp though? Really? 😀 I can see how that works for all the usual girls who won’t touch coding with a ten foot pole, but really..? I think the key idea here is that chicks who code often dislike going all out and dancing, or at least when anyone can see them..? I didn’t know this about this book… I find it quite amusing now 😀

    • Jamie

      Can confirm, do like to code, don’t like to dance. :'( A dance competition seems stereotypical for any other school scenario but not a code camp. I was surprised by this part of the book and disappointed that it took up a considerable portion.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge
Subscribe

Get the latest posts delivered to your mailbox: